Our History

Learn the Rich History of a Little Schoolhouse Turned Sanibel Jewelry Gallery

Lily & Co.’s building has a rich history, spanning more than 100 years on Sanibel. Constructed in 1915, the building on 520 Tarpon Bay Road was originally owned by the Florida Baptist Convention of Jacksonville. In 1929 the building opened as a school for African American children during Lee County’s efforts to update the educational facilities throughout the county. The school remained in service until around 1963, when the current Sanibel Elementary School, the island’s first integrated school was built.
At that time, the schoolhouse was converted into the “Schoolhouse Art Gallery.” And as the years went by, 520 Tarpon Bay Road served as a bank and a podiatrist’s office.

On July 8, 1999, the historic Sanibel School was added to the U.S. National Register of Historic Places and stands as one of only three historic schools for black children in Lee County. The Sanibel School is also one of 140 places recognized in the “Florida Black Heritage Trail,” first published in 1991 by the Florida Department of State, Division of Historical Resources.

In 2006, in a change from its origins, the store became Lily & Co. Jewelers, a Sanibel jewelry gallery combining a fine jewelry store and art gallery in one location. We are very proud of our building’s long heritage and invite all guests to drop in and travel back in time!

Our Services

You already know that Lily Jewelry is the ultimate destination for distinctive Sanibel jewelry and local fine art, but did you know we also offer jewelry and watch repair, custom designed jewelry and restyling, and even a purchase program for your previously worn pieces?

Whether you’re looking to buy or sell, come to Lily & Co. Jewelers first!

Custom Designed Jewelry From a Master Jeweler

Let Lily & Co.’s master jeweler, Nicholas De Stefano, craft that special piece of jewelry you’ve always dreamed of. He takes your vision and turns it into reality, putting his heart and soul into every custom piece he has the privilege of working on. Stop in to our Sanibel Island jewelry gallery and meet with our professionals to discuss your custom creation and see some of our exquisite creations.

Safe, Reliable Jewelry Repair

At Lily Jewelry, we understand that every piece of jewelry you own is a cherished possession, whether family heirlooms or new pieces. When you trust Lily Co. to the repair of your jewelry, you can rest easy knowing it will be safe and handled with the utmost of care while in our possession.

Our Sanibel jewelry repair services are completed and equipped with the most advanced technology available. Whether you need a basic repair or complex remounting job, you will work closely with us to ensure your complete satisfaction.

Sell Your Previously Worn Jewelry to Lily & Co. Jewelers

In addition to carrying new items from renowned designers around the world, we are always on the lookout to purchase distinctive previously worn merchandise from our customers. Through Lily’s P3 Purchase Program (Positively Precious Program), we will evaluate the valuables you wish to sell, which may include jewelry, fine stemware, rare coins, and luxury wristwatches. If you have an entire estate to liquidate, contact our Sanibel jewelers to see how we can help turn your treasures into cash.

Bring Your Dated Pieces to Lily Jewelry for Restyling

Are you hanging onto dated, out of style jewelry for sentimental reasons? Maybe you just don’t think it’s worth trying to update or sell? Whatever the reason, dig those pieces out of the bottom of your jewelry box and bring them to Lily Co.! Nicholas De Stefano and our professional staff will work with you on a vision for restyling your old jewelry, breathing new life back into it and creating a piece that reflects your personal taste and modern trends in jewelry design.

Sanibel Watch Repair and Battery Replacement

Lily & Company offers onsite battery replacement and even major repairs for when your ticker quits ticking. Before giving up on it, bring it to Lily Co. for a check-up from our Sanibel jewelry and watch experts. You can rest easy knowing we take excellent care of your treasured timepieces throughout their stay here on the island.

Our Designers

Lily & Co. Jewelers – In-House and World-Class Designers

At Lily & Co. Jewelers on Sanibel, you’re not going to find the same generic jewelry sold at mall chains. We specialize in distinctive jewelry from designers around the globe, and we’ve spent the past decade sourcing the finest silver, gold, platinum and precious gem pieces to represent the Lily Jewelry name.

Our Sanibel Island jewelry “family” lives and breathes the island life, and you’ll see that reflected in the stunning pieces that we hand-select from our preferred designers. For a truly local flavor, get immersed in the Lily Sea Life collection, or choose a delicate adornment from the Lily Diamond Collection; both new lines manufactured in-house and exclusive to Lily Co. Or, travel abroad to Florence, Italy for a bold, colorful statement piece from designer, Ponte Vecchio; or find the perfect silver fashion piece from renowned European manufacturer, Breuning.

Custom Designed Jewelry from Distinguished Lily Co. Jewelers

Not finding what you want, or do you have something very specific in mind? Stop by our Design Center and have a chat with master jewelers. Not only is our staff the masterminds behind our exclusive new in-house “Lily” collections, we can also create custom pieces born of your imagination. Bring us a picture from a magazine, a scribble on a cocktail napkin, or just sit down with us and talk about your vision for custom designed jewelry for you or a loved one.

Lily & Co. Jewelers is Sanibel Island’s first jewelry gallery, featuring exquisite collections from world-class designers.

Gurhan
The Touch
Charles Garnier
The Mazza Company
Bruening
Charles Krypell
Denny Wong
Doves
Fredrick Sage

KC Designs
Chelsea Clocks
Beny Sofer
Martin Flyer
Roberto DeMeglio
Mark Edwards
Marahlago
Belle étoile
JYE Luxury Collection